Menu of Old Town Ice Cream Co in Kissimmee, Florida, USA

Menu Overview

Old Town Ice Cream Co, nestled on W Irlo Bronson Memorial Hwy in Kissimmee, is a charming ice cream shop that masterfully blends nostalgia with quality. Walking inside, you immediately sense the old-time decor, evoking memories of classic American soda fountains, which sets a warm and inviting tone before even tasting a single scoop.

The menu at Old Town Ice Cream Co is delightfully diverse. Their hard ice cream selection—boasting around 16 to 20 flavors—offers everything from fruity to decadent, with standouts like the Very Berry Lemonade, Tropical Paradise, and Sunset Dream showcasing vibrant, refreshing profiles that are perfect for cooling down under Florida’s sun. These frozen house favorites are carefully crafted, with each bite delivering rich texture and balanced sweetness that feels both homemade and indulgent.

One notable highlight is their creative integration of classic and contemporary flavors: the Pina Colada, Corona, and Margarita selections add an adult twist, reflecting a playful nod to tropical cocktails, all served as ice cream or slushies, which perfectly complement the warm Kissimmee vibe. Additionally, the Banana Split pays homage to traditional ice cream parlor staples, skillfully presented and generously portioned.

The food offerings go beyond typical ice cream fare, which enriches the overall experience. Items like Garlic Knots, the Cheeseburger Combo, and Steak Sandwich provide savory counterpoints that satisfy more substantial cravings. This variety makes Old Town Ice Cream Co not just a dessert stop but a complete casual dining destination.

Drinks such as the Classic Soda, including the nostalgic A&W Root Beer—highlighted by customer Linda Wozniak—blend perfectly with the ice cream to round out the experience. The presence of hot chocolate and bottled water ensures there is something for every palate and weather condition, making this spot versatile.

Customer reviews reflect a community rekindling affection for this establishment, with remarks about its resurgence and fond memories of it being a “black market mineral shop”—a curious nugget that hints at its unique past. Though tucked inside an A&W restaurant, which Mark Genovese notes can make it a bit elusive, the experience rewards those who seek it out. Look for deals like the BOGB coupon in local activity flyers to enhance your visit.

In all, Old Town Ice Cream Co offers more than just ice cream—it delivers a multi-sensory journey through nostalgic ambiance, creative flavors, and complementary savory dishes. It’s a place where memories and tastes coexist, inviting guests to savor moments as much as the menu itself.